My starting point for judging an ad is to imagine being the poor sod who hasn’t read the brief. They’ve never met the client. They missed the bit in the presentation where everyone nodded. They’re halfway through something else and now here we are, talking about car hire.
Why should they care?
I’ve spent years on the agency side of that question. It’s surprisingly easy to lose sight of it once you know how hard everyone’s worked. These are the ten questions I’d have in the room, with a debt to David Ogilvy, Bill Bernbach, Paula Green and Rory Sutherland.
1. Why should I care?
Paula Green understood that nobody hiring a car gave a toss where Avis sat in the league table. What they cared about was how they’d be treated at the counter. “We try harder” connected the two. Ask what your commercial problem has to do with my life. That’s usually where the brief gets interesting.
2. What will make me stop?
Bernbach’s agency put a picture of a Volkswagen above the word “Lemon.” Now I’ve got a question. What’s wrong with the car? I’ll read the next line to find out. I love that kind of headline. The audience supplies the curiosity.
3. Will I enjoy the time I spend with you?
Make me laugh. Give me a story I want the end of. Show me something I’ll want to show my mate. Entertainment is a perfectly good reason to watch an ad. And if the joke is funny in the script, please resist the urge to have somebody explain it in the voiceover.
4. Is there something real here?
Love, envy, embarrassment, grief. All fair game, provided you’ve got something to say. Think of the little boy in John Lewis’s The Long Wait. He spends December willing Christmas to come, then runs straight past his own presents to give his parents theirs. That tiny reversal gets me. Anyone who’s ever been ridiculously excited to give someone a gift knows exactly how he feels.
5. What’s the one thing I’ll remember?
Ogilvy went digging through the detail on Rolls-Royce and found the electric clock. At 60 mph you could hear it. Try writing a better way to say the car is quiet. Then try doing it with six messages and a mandatory reference to craftsmanship.
6. Why should I believe you?
Back to that Volkswagen. What made it a lemon? The inspector had spotted a blemish on the glovebox trim and rejected the car. Imagine the alternative headline the client could have signed off. Our commitment to quality. Same brief. Quite a different ad.
7. Can you change how I see it?
This is where Rory Sutherland comes in. Take a pack of three sausages. Three can look a bit mean on a supermarket shelf. Now imagine you live on your own, you fancy sausages tonight and you’re sick of throwing food away. Suddenly three looks like someone’s given the matter some thought. Before you change the pack, have a go at changing what the pack means.
8. What’s the product doing in the best bit?
The test people associate with Bernbach came from Bob Levenson, his head of copy at DDB. Take the product out. Do you still love the ad? I’d ask it the morning after a creative presentation, especially if everyone’s still talking about how funny the dog was. What was the dog selling?
9. Is there another great ad in this?
Ogilvy asked whether an idea could run for 30 years. I’d settle for seeing the second execution before buying the first. Avis could talk about the ashtray, the tank or the queue at the counter. Each gave you another reason to believe the same three words. That’s a campaign I’d want to buy.
10. When it comes to choosing, what have we changed?
You can love an ad and forget who it was for. You can remember exactly who it was for and still see no reason to buy. So finish the thought from the customer’s side. I’d give Avis a go because… Green had an answer. Every ad we put in front of a client ought to have one too.
